’Children of Cain’: A difference of opinion?
Comments upon a forum dedicated to Craft issues, drawn from and based within an Interent posting of an Interview with Mr Howard [with Three Hands Press] concerning his new book, has brought several emails to my attention expressing divided opinion on the matter. Some approve a public response, others contest the subject as unfit for public consumption. And I agree with both for different reasons!
To this I add that general public statements and comments can and should largely be ignored. But when someone makes a statements from an assumed position of authority, this demands a careful and considered response to counter those statements by someone in an actual position of authority.
In point of fact, no-one may present themselves as having the definitive opinion on another’s tradition.
There is obviously a need for clarification on this matter once placed in the public domain. Without conclusion, all loose ends may at any time be rethreaded to generate misleading commentary, even if by others having no vested interest in the matter. In fact I agree wholeheartedly with Mr Howard view regarding this response to his online Interview that avidly promotes his forthcoming book – The Children of Cain’, when he said that there is wisdom in keeping these things private. Indeed! Would it had remained so. But as opinion was given by Mr Howard on points we know to be in errror, we seek to address them here.
It should be stressed that sometimes, just sometimes, there is a real need to make a stand for clarity and truth against anything that appears to undermine the integrity of one’s own purpose and work, even if no intentional malice or ill will was behind such acts. To ignore such erosions we invite doubt and cynicism to gnaw at the line of Virtue as if to sever it from its source. Those who would wish it cannot do this. We cannot do this. That is NOT our choice nor ability to manufacture.
With regard to the varied views and works of Robert Cochrane, other letters soon to be published in John of Monmouth’s forthcoming book will clarify much speculation there too. They reveal much that has been needful for some time.
So, in choosing to respectfully counter Mr Howard’s assertions within his Interview he holds on the Three Hands Press website, I hope that perhaps all can be laid to rest and the real Mysteries can be pursued without distraction, which I might add, the Clan continue to do with impunity. Being front man, it is my role and mine alone, to tackle such matters as I feel is necessary.
We also accept that though fascinating, the negative attention these matters can inadvertantly attract are tiring. We therefore remind interested parties to accept that we did not incur them. We did not encourage them. We merely wish to provide this response for balance, having previously failed to conclude them privately. Others return them to the public eye for scrutiny. So we try again to quell speculation with fact.
Virtue. A weighty and complex subject. It has been picked over clean on this site and others. But not in context. No one view of this is correct for the whole, only where it touches them. Our Covenant holds it as countless other mystics have for hundreds of years. Others may see it differently.
John [E.J. Jones] once described it to us during a time we had difficulty ourselves in grasping the enormity of this esoteric facet of Craft and of the Mysteries. We failed for a while to fully assimilate its mystery and import, and try as we may, we floundered. John finally broke his normal ‘Socratic method’ and expressed it in simple terms that cannot be beaten.
No-one passes ‘Virtue’. No-one owns ‘Virtue’. No-one gains Virtue. Each person has their own which should never be confused with that carried by a line or stream of practise. Shani expressed this well in turn when she alluded to the Dalai Lama, and how after death, that spiritual force finds a new host.
This host is sought out, discovered, recognised and dutifully installed as ‘head’ and spiritual leader, the mediating link between his people, the spirits and their deities. E, J. Jones humorously noted it was his duty to appoint that which is already vested in another, never his to give. What is ‘passed’ is not Virtue per se. Authority certainly is though once the host is recognised.
That Shani acquired that Virtue, is all that matters. How and when is irrelevant to that fact. Furthermore that same Virtue RC had guarded and shared through his wife and then Maid had in fact departed RC in his final weeks of life. This was his final despair. She also rejected it and so it found a new host.
But there is more. RC had in fact made E, J. Jones his spiritual heir long before his death, and his statement that he had died ‘without passing on his virtue’ refers in fact to his own, as a ‘witch/pellar’ that should have been gifted his physical heir, that is his son. This of course did not happen. This confused us as I said, so bear with me. John and his wife were the last people from the Clan to see Robert Cochrane before his death.
Robert Cochrane’s widow soon after withdrew from all remaining members of the former Clan but remained close to John and his wife, and to Bill and Bobby Gray. And to Doreen Valiente. These few [minus RC’s widow] worked magically together regularly to a greater and lesser degree over the years that followed, until finally they all went their separate ways.
The authority to continue as the Clan of Tubal Cain with all investiture and rights including all written works was then given by RC’s widow to John, appointing him as its Magister. E, J. Jones always considered himself the guardian and caretaker of that tradition and spent many years seeking the host where its Virtue resided. Mr Howard admitted himself that John’s own words described his elation when he ‘found’ that person in Shani, stating- ‘She is the one, the chosen one.’
The Covenant is the final declaration of this process as it binds in Troth the one appointed with authority to the tutelary deity through Virtue of recognition [literally]. E, J. Jones in assuming this was widely known among the older and more genuine Crafters, saw no reason to explain what to him was obvious.
In summary then:
RC’s personal virtue [the ‘fifth art’] *died with him.
RC’s spiritual virtue was gifted to John.
The Clan’s Virtue found its own new host.
John and others of the Clan DID continue the work, there was NO ‘break’ in continuity.
These facts have been stated many times by E, J.Jones and by ourselves, and I am very disapointed that Mr Howard has expressed a view contra to these facts, based entirely upon conjecture and personal opinion drawn in part, it seems, from the fact that John declined to share the then more discreet elements of Clan praxis with him. And why should he? It was his right to choose exactly what he did or did not say as he saw fit.
Again, as Mr Howard knows through private discussions between him and ourselves, John declined the same information to us, as he did almost all of the Clan’s teachings. It was his way. We had to find out those things ourselves through validating spirit contact through the egregore. When we did, he expanded upon each aspect. Mr Howard, being outside the Clan, was not engaged in that process. Thus the original Luciferian elements known to RC, and others, especially John, were discussed and explored under his tutelage and since, as is fitting for an evolving stream of gnosis.
A rolling stone gathers no moss!
Though lengthy, I sincerely hope this has more than clarified any confusion arising from various comments presented by Mr Howard’s Interview.
*[there are five arts, gifted between an old magister and his successor, four involve certain rights held through the medium of the egregore to call upon various spiritual numina for specific causalities. the fifth art is the gift of blood heritage, a direct link through dna between members of a physical family. this adds to the spiritual heritage another dimension parallel to it.]
Robin-the-dart
MAY THE WORD PROTECT YOU FROM THE LIE!









Across the ages, many plants have been ascribed special significance due to their propensity to induce spectacular, visionary and prophetic dreams. Particular plants have proved popular, cropping up in diverse locations and throughout many centuries with little fluctuation. Throughout the Old World, Mesoamerica, and Southern Continents, narcotic beverages have been administered to the ‘seers’ of a given tribe, culled from herbs sacred to them specifically, to ensure favourable results.
In truth, many plants fulfil the role of ‘love-divination,’ though none so popular as the rose. Within dream flora further popular plants that auger well for affairs of the heart are the raspberry, pomegranate, cucumber, currant, and box.
St John’s wort, the summer herb, sacred also to Balder is a potent herb for use in divination, though it must be gathered on Midsummer’s Eve. This is the trick, as it is said to carry off the picker on a fairy horse for a wild ride, only to be dropped hours later, miles from home. Sprigs of the evergreen Myrtle, sacred again to Aphrodite were kept under a bride’s pillow to ensure the constancy of her lover. Mattresses stuffed with the soft and fragrant new beech leaves whisper gently to all lovers asleep upon them, pervading their dreams with imaginative and complex tales and stories.
Dew collected from the Lady’s Mantle was allegedly used to seek and procure the famed philosophers stone, yet its crushed petals assisted in peaceful dreamless sleep. This is contra to the fragrant honeysuckle and hops that induce erotic dreams , featuring in many a lover’s summer bower. However, dreaming of fruit or flowers out of season is perceived as ill-omens of woe: “A bloom upon the apple-tree when the apples are ripe, Is a sure termination to somebody’s life.”






Roodmas, May’s Eve or Beltane celebrates this freedom of mental expansion, of growth induced by the awakening of the spirit within. Moreover, the avatar of initiation – Al Khidir, the spirit of the Green Man, triggers all this activity. Outwardly, he represents the fecundity of nature, of new life, re-generation and its fertility rites, themes that ‘mask’ his true virtues. Green tendrils issue from silent lips, breathing life and energy into oracular powers and divine speech, wisdom rises from his roots, rising like sap in to fresh growth, sprouting from these masked sprits, ‘guised’ aspects of primal energy.




